Modeling Forums
Internet Modeling
What's a good way to ask...
OK, by way of setting up this topic, let me relate something that happened to me at OMP. I was brand new to the photography game when I was on there...had maybe one or two shoots under my belt. I was surfing OMP and I came across a model's profile that I liked...
She had the "Fetish/Adult" box checked, so I thought it would be ok to make an initial contact. I'm a very polite guy...I made an initial inquiry with something like, "Hi, I'm Tony and I was wondering if you'd like to shoot with me...," adding on all the essential details such as rate of pay and the type of bondage I was going to do. I don't remember her reply verbatim, but it went something like this...
"NO. I wouldn't do bondage for even $5,000 an hour. Don't ever again message me, and seek professional help."
There may have been more...but those were the lines that stood out in my mind. First time I've ever offended a model...and I'd like to never do it again. If you don't like bondage, FINE...no need to be snarky about it...lol.
Flash-forward to today. I've come across many a model profile on MM and other places that doesn't have anything on the "About Me" one way or the other about fetish work, let alone "DID" bondage like I do. Question: how can I inquire about a shoot with someone without being aware of their stance on my type of work? I'd like to avoid another verbal-tounge lashing...is there a way I can ask without ruffling feathers?
Hot, desert bondage at TucsonTied... http://www.tucsontied.com/
Meh...If they don't say it up front one way or the other, you'll never know if you never ask. Just continue to be properly polite and professional in your inquiries and solicitations, and if they get bent, fuck 'em for not being professional and polite in return. Another check mark in the "next" list.
My profile vaguely mentions "fetish", so I had a photographer message me asking what "fetish" meant to me. I gave some examples of what I would and wouldn't do. If their profile doesn't say ANYTHING, maybe shoot them a note and ask about what their limits are?
Some people probably don't even understand what they mark as a gener...I do not feel that the OP was wrong for asking since the model had it marked...The same happends with adult work I have seen lots of models mark that as a gener but had no idea what it really was...Sometimes I guess you just have to ask and hope that who your contacting really understands what they are advertising..
Amanda wrote:
Some people probably don't even understand what they mark as a gener...I do not feel that the OP was wrong for asking since the model had it marked...The same happends with adult work I have seen lots of models mark that as a gener but had no idea what it really was...Sometimes I guess you just have to ask and hope that who your contacting really understands what they are advertising..
Obviously, she didn't. The thing that got under my skin was how snarky she was in her reply...I'm hoping to avoid that in the future.
Hot, desert bondage at TucsonTied... http://www.tucsontied.com/
Through out the years that I have been working with models, you really never know what kind of response you will come accross no matter what you ask about shooting. But one of my solid guidelines is to read over what the model states in the profile or what type of work they display in the portfolio pictures. For me, unless the model states that they are interested in nude work or there is nudity in the portfolio, I don't ask. If there is something that I am still interested in doing pictures of then make the connection during a shoot. Then approach the subject one on one. You should be able to get the feel if the model is interested in that type of work or not.
Marc/Tiny
It's one of the trickier areas, because people use these words in different ways; fetish in the context of a model site is such a catch-all, often stretched way beyond the dictionary definition. Bondage of course is pretty specific; wouldn't it be nice if every model would use precise words. But not all will.
Look at it this way: In the lifestyle fetish/bondage/bdsm real world, open communication is (theoretically) encouraged, and (again theoretically) yes means yes and no means no, and it's expected that one will ask and that no one will get offended as long as the exchange is civilized, no matter what the answer.
So: If she took offense, then she just wants to play dress up, and she doesn't understand the implications. I'd say patiently seek someone who is real, or at least wants to be, and ask in a diplomatic way without assuming in advance what the answer will be.
Tiny K wrote:
Through out the years that I have been working with models, you really never know what kind of response you will come accross no matter what you ask about shooting. But one of my solid guidelines is to read over what the model states in the profile or what type of work they display in the portfolio pictures. For me, unless the model states that they are interested in nude work or there is nudity in the portfolio, I don't ask. If there is something that I am still interested in doing pictures of then make the connection during a shoot. Then approach the subject one on one. You should be able to get the feel if the model is interested in that type of work or not.
Marc/Tiny
Marc...that's how I usually do things...TOTAL agreement with you. What bugs me, is the occasion where a friend of mine will write me and send me a link to a model port and say, "Look who I'm working with next," and there's absolutely no nudity/fetish/bondage on her page. (shrugs) Dunno how they do it...lmao.
But yeah...I'll continue to act above board and just be the polite guy I always am...best you can do, right?
Hot, desert bondage at TucsonTied... http://www.tucsontied.com/
Knomad One wrote:
I'd say patiently seek someone who is real, or at least wants to be, and ask in a diplomatic way without assuming in advance what the answer will be.
I quoted just the last line because it hit me like a brick...that's exactly what I was doing, wasn't I? Lesson learned...and thank you.
Incidentally, Rachel, if you're reading this, I'd be interested in your opinion...
Hot, desert bondage at TucsonTied... http://www.tucsontied.com/
She didn't need to be such a bitch about it. Sheesh.
I think the model responded back incorrectly and rather rudely but to each his own......you did nothing wrong by asking I would of done the same.
I've known models to check the "adult" boxes on OMP because they were over 21. Simply stated, some folks don't know the meanings of the stuff on various sites and don't take the time to find out.
As long as you're polite in your approach, who cares if the model gets rude in a reply? That's on her, not on you. (Same goes for models who get rude replies from photographers.)
Nothing ventured nothing gained.
Did a verbal tongue lashing actually hurt you in any way?
Nope, it did not.
You choose to live outside societies rules so you have chosen to have society tell you that once in a while.
It is the choice you made, if you want every one to agree with what you do give up the ropes and shoot kittens instead.
Just accept that for every 50 people you contact you will get 3 pieces of hate mail... accept it and live a happier life then those who live by others rules instead of their own.
Iona Lynn wrote:
Nothing ventured nothing gained.
Did a verbal tongue lashing actually hurt you in any way?
Nope, it did not.
You choose to live outside societies rules so you have chosen to have society tell you that once in a while.
It is the choice you made, if you want every one to agree with what you do give up the ropes and shoot kittens instead.
Just accept that for every 50 people you contact you will get 3 pieces of hate mail... accept it and live a happier life then those who live by others rules instead of their own.
Shoot KITTENS?! Fate worse than death, lovely lady...lol.
Yah, you're right...I'll never know until I ask...it's all about communication, isn't it? Thanks for that...made perfect sense.
Hot, desert bondage at TucsonTied... http://www.tucsontied.com/
I have been on the other side of this recently where I had set up a shoot with a photographer under the context of doing bodyscapes and 'part' nudes, which right before he slowly tried to push for the shoot to be something entirely different right before the date. I was more frustrated and annoyed with his sneakiness and non-straight forwardness. I prefer when a photographer/artist contacts me about collaborating they be direct about their intentions and vision. Politeness is always appreciate but it is most useful for them to ask if I am interested/willing to do what it is they are looking for. That way no toes are stepped on later on, and the miscommunication is minimized-seems to lead to happier parties all around. 
I know this is an old thread, but since TT is roughly in my area I want to know who it is so I can avoid them. She sounds like a PITA.
Gibson Photo Art wrote:
I know this is an old thread, but since TT is roughly in my area I want to know who it is so I can avoid them. She sounds like a PITA.
nothing wrong with reviving and old thread especially if it's new members that revive it. This place has grown a lot in 6 months.
Just ask. If they respond badly- that's THEIR fault for having no manners or communication skills. You certainly seem to have been perfectly upfront and polite in your request.
I have seen listings where a model has checked yes to nudity but when you read their profile they state they dont do nudity I wonder if they are pulling something or just arnt clever.
you could allways try the "3rd person" option if the model knows another model that might be open to that type of content.
that approach would make it a little less personal
I was going to try a similar approach with shy models by asking them to reply to my questions they might be personally uncomfortable with by thinking of themselves as a go between for a ficticious friend. my thinking is that it would allow them to be objective.
brent847 wrote:
I have seen listings where a model has checked yes to nudity but when you read their profile they state they dont do nudity I wonder if they are pulling something or just arnt clever.
They might have changed their minds and forgotten to uncheck the box. She might say it in her profile to deter certain photographers. She might have inadvertently checked the box when setting up other things she was interested in. Assuming a model is an idiot isn't really all that cool.
brent847 wrote:
you could allways try the "3rd person" option if the model knows another model that might be open to that type of content.
that approach would make it a little less personal
I was going to try a similar approach with shy models by asking them to reply to my questions they might be personally uncomfortable with by thinking of themselves as a go between for a ficticious friend. my thinking is that it would allow them to be objective.
If I got a message from a photographer that said, "do you know anyone who's interested in X, Y or Z?" I'd answer them honestly and then be done with it. Either I'd recommend people (and I have), or I wouldn't because I didn't know, and I'll let him know. I most certainly wouldn't assume it was a passive-aggressive way of him asking me if *I* was interested in that, especially if it was something I said I wasn't interested in doing.
Better to be honest than skirt around the issue, and just ask directly if you want to know.
Rachel Jay
My Modeling Blog: Thoughts of a Hobbyist Model
My Style Blog: Suburban Style Challenge
I'm the Internet Modeling Forum Host here at MI
Feel free to ask me questions.
Whatever seems like a prety simple fix to uncheck a box
If I got a message from a photographer that said, "do you know anyone who's interested in X, Y or Z?" I'd answer them honestly and then be done with it. Either I'd recommend people (and I have), or I wouldn't because I didn't know, and I'll let him know. I most certainly wouldn't assume it was a passive-aggressive way of him asking me if *I* was interested in that, especially if it was something I said I wasn't interested in doing.
Better to be honest than skirt around the issue, and just ask directly if you want to know.
very true ive even been debating about using the 3rd person approach with shy models because if they arnt adult or mature enough to talk through an interview/audition there would most likely be more difficulties down the road like during the shoot.
brent847 wrote:
Whatever seems like a prety simple fix to uncheck a box
Many models manage multiple profiles on a variety of modeling sites. I personally have profiles on MI, MM, OMP, Illinois Modeling Network, Green Martini, Model Brigade, and Paid Models, just off the top of my head. Oh, and FaceBook and MySpace, plus a blog. It's rather easy to overlook something. In fact, I know that my MB and PM profiles are out of date... but I never get work from either of those sites, because most of the membership overlaps on MI and/or MM, so I choose to make sure my profiles are updated on the sites I get work from. The others, I see as... a spot to secure my username.
brent847 wrote:
very true ive even been debating about using the 3rd person approach with shy models because if they arnt adult or mature enough to talk through an interview/audition there would most likely be more difficulties down the road like during the shoot.
If a model is shy, asking her if she can recommend friends to you isn't going to bring her out of her shell. In fact, as a newer photographer, I wouldn't recommend working with a shy model until you've worked with some who are less shy. You'll find the more experience YOU have, the easier it will be for YOU to help shier models open up during a shoot. And I'm talking in general, not when it comes to them getting naked. In many cases, being shy has nothing to do with getting naked. Ask around, and you'll find that I'm far from shy, yet I won't shoot nude.
Rachel Jay
My Modeling Blog: Thoughts of a Hobbyist Model
My Style Blog: Suburban Style Challenge
I'm the Internet Modeling Forum Host here at MI
Feel free to ask me questions.
brent847 wrote:
very true ive even been debating about using the 3rd person approach with shy models because if they arnt adult or mature enough to talk through an interview/audition there would most likely be more difficulties down the road like during the shoot.
If a model is shy, asking her if she can recommend friends to you isn't going to bring her out of her shell.
ah sorry, you missunderstood what I ment here, what i was trying to says is that if a shy model was having trouble answering questions directly about... lets say posing in a bubble bath and the water level (nude or implied) I was trying to say that it might be easier if they were talking about a ficticious model friend doing a bubblebath theme and answering the question "for" their friend suposidly it allows the person to become objective its a displacement tactic like if someone doesnt want to talk about themself.
but your right being direct and honest is the best approach.
Your best bet is to be direct when communicating with models. Largely, it will lessen the confusion, and that will lessen the possibility of drama should you actually a book a shoot.
Playing games, pretending there's a third person, going back and forth about pre-shoot contracts, and bullshit like that is a huge waste of time for a model, especially if she's one who's serious about modeling.
Rachel Jay
My Modeling Blog: Thoughts of a Hobbyist Model
My Style Blog: Suburban Style Challenge
I'm the Internet Modeling Forum Host here at MI
Feel free to ask me questions.
Brent . . . I have a (strong) recommendation for you:
Do not shoot nudes. Do not shoot implied nudes. Do not shoot anything even a little bit suggestive of nudity until you have at least 15 photography sessions with models done successfully. Just don't.
Bob was on to something. Between lack of experience, an apparent difficulty in relating to women, and your considerable interest in nudity, you are heading down a path that leads to problems. Really. Get some experience with models - a fair amount of it - before you even consider doing anything involving naked girls.
Modeling Forums
Internet Modeling
What's a good way to ask...